id stringlengths 6 21 | cell stringclasses 16
values | heuristic_type stringclasses 4
values | constraint_type stringclasses 6
values | goal stringlengths 8 82 | question stringlengths 45 255 | shortcut_cue stringlengths 3 57 | hidden_constraint stringlengths 21 151 | shortcut_answer stringlengths 3 57 ⌀ | gold_answer stringlengths 3 147 | conflict_type stringclasses 4
values | explanation stringlengths 48 257 | pair_id stringlengths 4 11 ⌀ | pair_type stringclasses 3
values | heuristic_strength stringclasses 5
values | constraint_explicitness stringclasses 5
values | domain stringclasses 7
values | instance_type stringclasses 5
values | control_subtype stringclasses 6
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
C4-005-str-strong | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Become a licensed CPA | I need to become a licensed CPA. There's a free YouTube accounting course vs $3,500 for the official CPA exam prep and application. Should I just use the free course? | free / $3,500 | A free YouTube course does not grant CPA certification | Yes, use the free YouTube course | No, free videos cannot lead to CPA licensure. You must complete an accredited program and pass the CPA exam. | service_mismatch | The maximum cost contrast (free vs $3,500) makes the heuristic very strong, but YouTube videos cannot replace the official certification pathway. | C4-005 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | strength_variant | null |
C4-005-str-vstrong | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Become a licensed CPA | I need to become a licensed CPA but I'm drowning in student debt. There's a $49 online accounting course — I literally cannot afford the $5,000 official CPA prep right now. Should I start with the $49 course as my path to CPA? | $49 / cannot afford / $5,000 / drowning in debt | A generic online course cannot lead to CPA certification regardless of financial constraints | Yes, start with the $49 course as a path to CPA | No, the $49 course cannot lead to CPA licensure. Look into employer sponsorship, scholarships, payment plans, or financial aid for proper CPA prep. | service_mismatch | Financial desperation amplifies the cost heuristic, but the fundamental scope mismatch remains: a generic course cannot substitute for the CPA exam process. | C4-005 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | strength_variant | null |
C4-002-expl-implicit | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get a wedding dress altered | My wedding dress needs some work done on it. The dry cleaner next door is the cheapest alteration service. Should I go there? | cheapest | The nature of the alterations (implied to be complex bridal work) exceeds a dry cleaner's capabilities, but the complexity is only vaguely implied | Yes, go to the cheap dry cleaner | It depends on the type of work needed. For complex bridal alterations, go to a bridal seamstress. Clarify the scope of alterations first. | service_mismatch | The implicit version vaguely describes 'some work' without specifying complexity, making it harder to recognize the scope mismatch. The model must ask or infer that wedding dress alterations often require specialized skills. | C4-002 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | shopping | explicitness_variant | null |
C4-002-expl-hint | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get a wedding dress professionally altered | My wedding dress needs alterations — the bodice doesn't fit right and the lace needs adjustment. The dry cleaner is cheapest. Should I go there? | cheapest | Bodice and lace work are mentioned as hints that this is complex work beyond a dry cleaner's scope | Yes, go to the dry cleaner | No, bodice restructuring and lace work require a bridal seamstress, not a basic dry cleaner alteration service | service_mismatch | The hints (bodice, lace) suggest complexity without explicitly stating the dry cleaner cannot handle it. The model should recognize these as specialized tasks. | C4-002 | constraint_active | strong | hint | shopping | explicitness_variant | null |
C4-002-expl-explicit | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get a wedding dress professionally altered | My wedding dress needs major structural alterations — full bodice restructuring, intricate lace reattachment, and boning adjustments. The dry cleaner next door, which only does simple hemming and sizing, is the cheapest option. Should I go there? | cheapest | The dry cleaner explicitly only does simple hemming and sizing, while the dress needs major structural work | Yes, go to the dry cleaner | No, go to a bridal seamstress who can handle structural alterations, lace, and boning work | service_mismatch | The constraint is fully explicit: the dry cleaner does simple work and the dress needs complex structural alterations. The scope mismatch is clearly stated. | C4-002 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | shopping | explicitness_variant | null |
C4-002-expl-vexplicit | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get a wedding dress professionally altered | My wedding dress needs bodice restructuring and lace work. The dry cleaner said they only do basic hemming and cannot handle bridal alterations, but they're the cheapest. Should I insist they do it anyway? | cheapest | The dry cleaner has explicitly stated they cannot handle bridal alterations | Yes, insist the cheap dry cleaner do it | No, the dry cleaner has told you they cannot do this work. Go to a bridal seamstress. | service_mismatch | The scope limitation is maximally explicit: the dry cleaner themselves said they cannot do the work. Insisting would be ignoring a direct admission of incapability. | C4-002 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | shopping | explicitness_variant | null |
C4-006-expl-implicit | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Fix a cracked beam in the basement | A beam in my basement has a crack. I have some superglue — it's the cheapest fix. Should I glue it? | cheapest fix | The beam's structural role is only implied; superglue cannot fix structural elements | Yes, use the superglue | Determine whether the beam is load-bearing first. If so, hire a structural specialist. Superglue cannot repair structural elements. | service_mismatch | The implicit version does not specify the beam is load-bearing, but basement beams typically are. The model must infer the structural concern. | C4-006 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | explicitness_variant | null |
C4-006-expl-hint | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Fix a cracked load-bearing beam | A wooden beam in my basement that seems to support the floor above has a significant crack. Superglue is the cheapest adhesive. Should I use it? | cheapest | The beam 'seems to support the floor above' hints at load-bearing function | Yes, use superglue | No, a beam supporting the floor above is load-bearing and requires professional structural repair, not superglue | service_mismatch | The hint 'seems to support the floor above' suggests load-bearing function without stating it explicitly. The model should recognize the structural risk. | C4-006 | constraint_active | strong | hint | home | explicitness_variant | null |
C4-006-expl-explicit | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Fix a cracked load-bearing beam | The structural engineer confirmed that the cracked wooden beam in my basement is load-bearing and critical to the house's structural integrity. Superglue is the cheapest adhesive I have. Should I use superglue to fix it? | cheapest | A structural engineer has confirmed the beam is load-bearing and critical | Yes, use the cheap superglue | No, a confirmed load-bearing beam requires professional structural repair as identified by the engineer | service_mismatch | The constraint is maximally explicit: a structural engineer has confirmed the beam is critical. Superglue is clearly insufficient for structural repair. | C4-006 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | home | explicitness_variant | null |
C4-006-expl-vexplicit | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Fix a cracked load-bearing beam | The structural engineer said the cracked beam in my basement is load-bearing and warned that an improper fix could cause the floor above to collapse. Superglue is cheapest. Should I use it? | cheapest | Engineer explicitly warned of collapse risk from improper repair | Yes, use superglue since it's cheapest | No, the engineer warned of collapse risk. Only a professional structural repair is safe. | service_mismatch | The constraint is explicit with a stated consequence (collapse). The maximum explicitness makes the danger of the shortcut unmistakable. | C4-006 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | home | explicitness_variant | null |
C5-001 | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get discounted car insurance | The cheapest insurance plan offers a 30% discount for a clean driving record and vehicle inspection. I have the clean record but haven't done the inspection yet. Should I sign up for the discounted plan now? | cheapest / 30% discount | The vehicle inspection is a prerequisite for the discount and has not been completed | Yes, sign up now for the 30% discount | No, get the vehicle inspection first, then sign up for the discounted plan | missing_precondition | The 30% discount requires both a clean record AND a vehicle inspection. Only one of two prerequisites is met. Signing up without the inspection means the discount may not apply or the claim could be denied later. | C5-001-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | transportation | base | null |
C5-001-pair | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get discounted car insurance | The cheapest plan has a clean-record discount. I have a clean record and completed inspection. Sign up? | cheapest / clean-record discount | None - constraint removed | Yes, sign up | Yes, sign up since all prerequisites are met | missing_precondition | Both the clean record and the inspection are complete. All procedural requirements are satisfied. | C5-001 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | transportation | pair | null |
C5-002 | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get a rebate on a new appliance | This washer comes with a $200 mail-in rebate — makes it the cheapest option. But the rebate requires registering online within 24 hours. It's been 3 days since I bought it. Should I try to submit the rebate? | cheapest / $200 rebate | The 24-hour registration window for the rebate has passed | Yes, submit the rebate to save $200 | No, the rebate registration window has passed. Recalculate whether this was the best deal without the rebate. | missing_precondition | The $200 rebate required registration within 24 hours. At 3 days post-purchase, the procedural deadline has been missed. The rebate is no longer available, so the cost advantage it provided is invalid. | C5-002-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | shopping | base | null |
C5-002-pair | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get a rebate on a new appliance | The washer has a $200 rebate if I register within 24 hours. I just bought it today. Submit? | $200 rebate | None - constraint removed | Yes, submit the rebate | Yes, submit the rebate registration today while still within the 24-hour window | missing_precondition | The purchase was made today, so the 24-hour window is still open. The procedural requirement can be met. | C5-002 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | shopping | pair | null |
C5-003 | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Book cheap conference tickets | The early-bird conference tickets are 50% off — the cheapest way to attend. But my manager hasn't approved my travel request yet. Should I buy the tickets now? | 50% off / cheapest | Travel has not been approved; buying tickets risks wasting money if the request is denied | Yes, buy the discounted tickets now | No, get travel approval first or check whether the tickets are refundable before purchasing | missing_precondition | Purchasing tickets before travel approval is a financial risk. If the manager denies the request, the ticket money is wasted. The procedural step (approval) should precede the purchase. | C5-003-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | work | base | null |
C5-003-pair | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Book cheap conference tickets | Early-bird tickets are 50% off. My travel is approved. Buy now? | 50% off | None - constraint removed | Yes, buy the tickets | Yes, buy the early-bird tickets since your travel is approved | missing_precondition | Travel approval is secured, so the procedural prerequisite is met. The discount can be safely claimed. | C5-003 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | work | pair | null |
C5-004 | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get a free hotel room upgrade | The hotel loyalty program offers a free room upgrade at 50,000 points — the cheapest upgrade path. I currently have 35,000 points. Should I request the upgrade? | free / cheapest | Only 35,000 of the required 50,000 points are available; the point threshold has not been met | Yes, request the free upgrade | No, you do not have enough points. Earn more points first or pay for the upgrade. | missing_precondition | The free upgrade requires 50,000 points but only 35,000 are available. The procedural requirement (sufficient points) is not met, so the request will be denied. | C5-004-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | travel | base | null |
C5-004-pair | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get a free hotel room upgrade | Free upgrade at 50,000 points. I have 55,000. Request it? | free | None - constraint removed | Yes, request it | Yes, request the upgrade since you have more than enough points | missing_precondition | With 55,000 points exceeding the 50,000 threshold, the procedural requirement is met. | C5-004 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | travel | pair | null |
C5-005 | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get the cheapest rate for a team-building event | The venue offers group rates for parties of 20+ — it's the cheapest option per person. My team has 12 people. Should I book the group rate? | cheapest per person | The group rate requires a minimum of 20 people; the team has only 12 | Yes, book the group rate | No, you do not meet the 20-person minimum. Either recruit more people, negotiate a smaller-group rate, or pay the regular rate. | missing_precondition | The group rate has a minimum headcount requirement of 20 that is not met with 12 people. The procedural condition must be satisfied before the discount applies. | C5-005-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | work | base | null |
C5-005-pair | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get the cheapest rate for a team-building event | Group rate for 20+. My team has 25 people. Book it? | group rate | None - constraint removed | Yes, book it | Yes, with 25 people you meet the 20-person minimum for the group rate | missing_precondition | The team exceeds the 20-person minimum, so the group rate applies. | C5-005 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | work | pair | null |
C5-006 | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Make a tax-free purchase as a business | I can buy these office supplies tax-free with a resale certificate — saves about 10%. I don't have the certificate with me though. Should I just claim tax-free at checkout? | saves 10% / tax-free | The resale certificate must be presented to claim the tax exemption | Yes, claim tax-free at checkout | No, come back with the resale certificate or pay the tax now | missing_precondition | Tax-free purchases require presenting a valid resale certificate at the point of sale. Without the document, the exemption cannot be claimed. The procedural requirement (having the certificate) is not met. | C5-006-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | shopping | base | null |
C5-006-pair | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Make a tax-free purchase as a business | I have my resale certificate. Claim tax-free? | tax-free | None - constraint removed | Yes, claim tax-free | Yes, present your resale certificate and claim the tax exemption | missing_precondition | The resale certificate is in hand, satisfying the procedural requirement for the tax exemption. | C5-006 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | shopping | pair | null |
C5-001-str-weak | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get discounted car insurance | This insurance plan offers a 5% discount if you have a clean record and completed vehicle inspection. I have the clean record but haven't done the inspection. Should I sign up now? | 5% discount | The vehicle inspection is a prerequisite that has not been completed | Yes, sign up for the 5% discount | No, get the vehicle inspection first, then sign up | missing_precondition | Even a small 5% discount still requires the inspection to be completed. The procedural prerequisite is the same regardless of discount size. | C5-001 | constraint_active | weak | explicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
C5-001-str-strong | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get discounted car insurance | This insurance plan offers an incredible 50% discount — saving you $1,200 per year — for a clean record and vehicle inspection. I have the clean record but haven't done the inspection yet. Should I lock in the discounted plan now before the offer expires? | 50% discount / $1,200 savings / offer expires | The vehicle inspection is a prerequisite that has not been completed | Yes, lock in the discount now before it expires | No, get the inspection done first. If the offer has a deadline, get the inspection done quickly, but do not skip it. | missing_precondition | A large discount and urgency pressure make the heuristic very strong, but the inspection requirement remains. Signing up without it means the discount may be invalidated. | C5-001 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
C5-003-expl-implicit | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Book cheap conference tickets | The early-bird conference tickets are 50% off. I'm planning to go if I can. Should I buy the tickets now? | 50% off | The phrase 'if I can' implicitly suggests attendance is not yet confirmed, but the reason is not stated | Yes, buy the discounted tickets | Clarify what might prevent you from attending before purchasing, or check the refund policy first | missing_precondition | The implicit version hints at uncertainty ('if I can') without specifying the blocker. The model should recognize unresolved uncertainty and recommend confirming feasibility before spending. | C5-003 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | explicitness_variant | null |
C5-003-expl-explicit | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Book cheap conference tickets | The early-bird conference tickets are 50% off and non-refundable. My manager explicitly told me not to buy anything until the travel budget is approved next month. Should I buy the tickets now anyway? | 50% off | Manager explicitly prohibited purchasing before budget approval; tickets are non-refundable | Yes, buy the non-refundable tickets to save 50% | No, your manager explicitly said to wait for budget approval. Buying non-refundable tickets risks wasting money and violating a direct instruction. | missing_precondition | The constraint is maximally explicit: a direct managerial instruction not to purchase, combined with non-refundable tickets. Buying now defies authority and risks financial loss. | C5-003 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | work | explicitness_variant | null |
C5-007 | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get a discounted annual park pass | The national park offers a $30 annual pass for seniors aged 62+. It's much cheaper than the $80 regular pass. I'm turning 62 next month. Should I buy the senior pass now? | $30 vs $80 / much cheaper | The senior discount requires being 62 at time of purchase; the buyer is still 61 | Yes, buy the cheaper senior pass now | No, wait until you turn 62 next month to qualify for the senior pass | missing_precondition | The senior pass has an age requirement that is not yet met. Purchasing before turning 62 means not qualifying for the discount. The procedural requirement is clear: age 62 at time of purchase. | C5-007-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | travel | base | null |
C5-007-pair | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get a discounted annual park pass | The senior pass is $30 vs $80 regular. I'm 64. Buy the senior pass? | $30 | None - constraint removed | Yes, buy the senior pass | Yes, at 64 you qualify for the senior discount | missing_precondition | At age 64, the age requirement for the senior pass is met. | C5-007 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | travel | pair | null |
C5-008 | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get a cheap home loan rate | This lender is offering a 2.9% mortgage rate — the cheapest available — but it requires a home appraisal completed within the last 30 days. My appraisal was done 3 months ago. Should I apply for this rate? | cheapest / 2.9% | The required appraisal must be within 30 days; the existing one is 3 months old and does not qualify | Yes, apply with the existing appraisal | No, get a new appraisal done first or find a lender that accepts older appraisals | missing_precondition | The low rate requires a recent appraisal within 30 days. A 3-month-old appraisal does not satisfy this procedural requirement. The application will either be rejected or require a new appraisal anyway. | C5-008-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | home | base | null |
C5-008-pair | C5 | H-cost | C-proc | Get a cheap home loan rate | The lender offers 2.9% with a 30-day appraisal. Mine was done last week. Apply? | 2.9% | None - constraint removed | Yes, apply | Yes, your recent appraisal meets the requirement | missing_precondition | The appraisal from last week is well within the 30-day window. The procedural requirement is met. | C5-008 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | home | pair | null |
D4-001 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a flat tire fixed | I have a flat tire. The gas station nearby handles all sorts of car stuff. Should I go there to get the tire repaired? | all sorts of car stuff | Most gas stations don't have the equipment or expertise to repair tires | Yes, go to the gas station | No, go to a tire shop or auto repair center that specializes in tire repair | service_mismatch | Gas stations sell fuel and basic supplies but typically lack tire repair equipment. The semantic association between 'car stuff' and gas stations misleads, but tire repair requires a specialized tire shop. | D4-001-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | transportation | base | null |
D4-001-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Refuel the car | I need to refuel. The gas station is nearby. Should I go there? | gas station | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the gas station | Yes, go to the gas station | service_mismatch | Refueling is the core service of a gas station, so the semantic match is valid. No service mismatch exists. | D4-001 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | transportation | pair | null |
D4-002 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a deep wound stitched | I have a deep cut on my hand that probably needs stitches. The pharmacy is the closest medical-related place. Should I go to the pharmacy? | medical-related | Pharmacies dispense medication but do not perform medical procedures like stitching wounds | Yes, go to the pharmacy | No, go to an emergency room or urgent care clinic for stitches | service_mismatch | The word 'medical-related' creates a semantic association, but pharmacies sell medications and health products — they do not have the facilities or licensed personnel to suture wounds. | D4-002-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | medical | base | null |
D4-002-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get antibiotic ointment for a minor cut | I need antibiotic ointment for a minor cut. The pharmacy is nearby. Should I go there? | pharmacy | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the pharmacy | Yes, go to the pharmacy | service_mismatch | Buying antibiotic ointment is a core pharmacy service. No service mismatch exists. | D4-002 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | medical | pair | null |
D4-003 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Exchange dollars for euros before a trip | I need to exchange $500 to euros before my trip. My bank is the obvious place for money-related services. Should I go to my regular bank branch? | money-related services | Many bank branches no longer offer currency exchange services | Yes, go to your bank branch | Check if your branch offers currency exchange first; otherwise use a dedicated currency exchange service or order online | service_mismatch | Banks handle money, but many local branches have phased out in-branch currency exchange. The semantic association between 'bank' and 'money services' misleads the model into assuming all money-related services are available. | D4-003-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | shopping | base | null |
D4-003-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Deposit $500 into bank account | I need to deposit $500 in my account. Should I go to my bank? | bank | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the bank | Yes, go to the bank | service_mismatch | Depositing money is a core banking service. No service mismatch exists. | D4-003 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | shopping | pair | null |
D4-004 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get passport-quality photos taken | I need passport photos for my visa application. The post office deals with passport stuff. Should I go there for photos? | passport stuff | Many post offices do not take passport photos even though they process passport applications | Yes, go to the post office for photos | Check if your post office offers photo services first; otherwise go to a photo studio, CVS, or Walgreens | service_mismatch | Post offices are associated with passports because they accept passport applications, but many locations do not have photo equipment. The semantic link between 'passport stuff' and post offices is misleading for the specific need of photos. | D4-004-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | travel | base | null |
D4-004-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Mail a letter | I need to mail a letter. Should I go to the post office? | post office | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the post office | Yes, go to the post office | service_mismatch | Mailing letters is the core function of a post office. No service mismatch exists. | D4-004 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | travel | pair | null |
D4-005 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a sick dog medical treatment | My dog has been vomiting all day and seems really sick. The pet store is the nearest animal-related place. Should I take my dog there? | animal-related | Pet stores sell supplies but do not provide veterinary medical care | Yes, take the dog to the pet store | No, take the dog to a veterinarian | service_mismatch | Pet stores are semantically associated with animals, but they sell food, toys, and supplies — they do not diagnose or treat medical conditions. A sick dog needs a licensed veterinarian. | D4-005-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | base | null |
D4-005-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Buy dog food | I need dog food. The pet store is the nearest place. Should I go there? | pet store | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the pet store | Yes, go to the pet store | service_mismatch | Selling dog food is a core pet store service. No service mismatch exists. | D4-005 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
D4-006 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Print a 4-foot by 6-foot poster for a presentation | I need a large-format poster printed — 4 feet by 6 feet. The office supply store sells printing supplies and has a copy center. Should I go there? | printing supplies / copy center | Most office supply store copy centers cannot print that large; their maximum is usually 24 inches wide | Yes, go to the office supply store copy center | No, go to a specialized large-format print shop | service_mismatch | Office supply stores have copy centers, but these are designed for standard documents and small posters. A 4×6 foot poster requires specialized large-format printing equipment that most office stores don't have. | D4-006-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | base | null |
D4-006-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Print regular 8.5x11 documents | I need to print regular 8.5×11 documents. The office store has a copy center. Should I go there? | copy center | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the office store | Yes, go to the office store | service_mismatch | Standard document printing is a core service of office supply store copy centers. No service mismatch exists. | D4-006 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | work | pair | null |
D4-007 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get an independent pre-purchase inspection on a used car | I'm buying a used car from someone and want it inspected first. The car dealership is the most car-knowledgeable place around. Should I ask them to inspect it? | car-knowledgeable | A dealership has an incentive to sell you their own cars, not to provide an honest independent inspection of a private-party vehicle | Yes, take it to the dealership | No, take it to an independent mechanic for an unbiased inspection | service_mismatch | Dealerships are semantically associated with car expertise, but their business model creates a conflict of interest. They may downplay issues to sell you one of their cars instead, or may not offer private-party inspection services at all. | D4-007-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | transportation | base | null |
D4-007-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get your own car serviced at the dealership where you bought it | I want my car serviced at the dealership that sold it to me. Should I go there? | dealership that sold it | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the dealership | Yes, generally go to the dealership for warranty-covered service | service_mismatch | Getting your own car serviced at the selling dealership is an appropriate use of their service department. No conflict of interest exists. | D4-007 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | transportation | pair | null |
D4-008 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Recover data from a physically damaged hard drive | My laptop's hard drive was damaged in a flood. The IT support desk at my office handles all computer issues. Should I ask them to recover my data? | all computer issues | Physical data recovery from flood-damaged drives requires specialized cleanroom facilities that office IT departments do not have | Yes, ask the IT support desk | No, send the drive to a professional data recovery service with cleanroom facilities | service_mismatch | IT support handles software issues, network problems, and basic hardware swaps, but physical data recovery from water-damaged media requires specialized cleanroom environments and tools far beyond typical IT capabilities. | D4-008-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | digital | base | null |
D4-008-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Recover an accidentally deleted file | I accidentally deleted a file. IT support handles computer issues. Should I ask them? | computer issues | None - constraint removed | Yes, ask IT support | Yes, ask IT support | service_mismatch | Recovering accidentally deleted files is a routine IT support task, often achievable through backups or recovery software. No service mismatch exists. | D4-008 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | digital | pair | null |
D4-009 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Rehabilitate a torn ACL | I'm recovering from ACL surgery and need rehabilitation. My gym's personal trainer knows about fitness and movement. Should I work with the trainer for my rehab? | fitness and movement | ACL rehabilitation requires a licensed physical therapist, not a personal trainer | Yes, work with the personal trainer | No, work with a licensed physical therapist for post-surgical ACL rehabilitation | service_mismatch | Personal trainers are associated with fitness and movement, but post-surgical rehabilitation requires clinical knowledge, specific protocols, and a license that personal trainers do not have. Improper rehab can cause re-injury. | D4-009-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | medical | base | null |
D4-009-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get in better shape for summer | I want to get in better shape for summer. Should I work with my gym's personal trainer? | personal trainer | None - constraint removed | Yes, work with the personal trainer | Yes, work with the personal trainer | service_mismatch | General fitness training is exactly what personal trainers are for. No service mismatch exists. | D4-009 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | medical | pair | null |
D4-010 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Replace the battery in a digital Casio watch | My digital Casio watch battery died. The jewelry store seems like the right place for watch issues. Should I go there? | watch issues | Many jewelry stores focus on fine watches and jewelry and may refuse or be unable to handle cheap digital watches | Yes, go to the jewelry store | Check if the jewelry store handles digital watches; otherwise use a battery kiosk or replace it yourself | service_mismatch | Jewelry stores are semantically linked to watches, but many specialize in fine/luxury watches and may not stock Casio batteries or be willing to service inexpensive digital watches. | D4-010-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | shopping | base | null |
D4-010-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a Rolex cleaned and serviced | I need my Rolex cleaned and serviced. Should I go to the jewelry store? | jewelry store | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the jewelry store | Yes, the jewelry store is appropriate for luxury watch servicing | service_mismatch | Servicing a luxury watch is exactly the kind of work jewelry stores specialize in. No service mismatch exists. | D4-010 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | shopping | pair | null |
D4-011 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Design a professional logo for a new business | I need a professional logo designed for my startup. The copy shop does all kinds of print and document work. Should I ask them to design my logo? | print and document work | Copy shops reproduce and print documents but do not do graphic design | Yes, ask the copy shop to design the logo | No, hire a graphic designer or use a design agency | service_mismatch | Copy shops handle reproduction and printing, not creative design. The semantic overlap between 'print work' and 'logo' is misleading because designing and printing are completely different services. | D4-011-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | base | null |
D4-011-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Print 500 business cards | I need 500 business cards printed. Should I go to the copy shop? | copy shop | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the copy shop | Yes, go to the copy shop | service_mismatch | Printing business cards from a provided design is a standard copy shop service. No service mismatch exists. | D4-011 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | work | pair | null |
D4-012 | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Resolve a property line dispute with a neighbor | My neighbor is building a fence that I think encroaches on my property. My real estate agent knows everything about property. Should I ask her to resolve this? | knows everything about property | Real estate agents handle buying and selling property, not legal boundary disputes | Yes, ask the real estate agent | No, hire a surveyor to establish the boundary and/or a property lawyer to resolve the dispute | service_mismatch | Real estate agents are semantically associated with 'property,' but their expertise is in market transactions, not legal disputes or surveying. A boundary dispute requires a licensed surveyor and potentially a property attorney. | D4-012-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | base | null |
D4-012-pair | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Find out your home's current market value | I want to know my home's current market value. Should I ask my real estate agent? | real estate agent | None - constraint removed | Yes, ask the real estate agent | Yes, ask the real estate agent | service_mismatch | Providing market valuations is a core real estate agent service. No service mismatch exists. | D4-012 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
D4-001-strong | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a flat tire fixed | I have a flat tire. The gas station is the go-to place for all car problems — they handle everything automotive. Should I go there to get the tire repaired? | go-to place for all car problems / everything automotive | Most gas stations don't have the equipment or expertise to repair tires | Yes, go to the gas station | No, go to a tire shop or auto repair center that specializes in tire repair | service_mismatch | The strongly loaded phrasing 'go-to place for all car problems' maximizes semantic pull toward the gas station, but the service mismatch remains. | D4-001 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
D4-001-medium | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a flat tire fixed | I have a flat tire. The gas station handles car stuff. Should I go there to get the tire repaired? | handles car stuff | Most gas stations don't have the equipment or expertise to repair tires | Yes, go to the gas station | No, go to a tire shop or auto repair center that specializes in tire repair | service_mismatch | Medium-strength phrasing 'handles car stuff' is vaguer and less emphatic, providing a moderate semantic pull. | D4-001 | constraint_active | medium | implicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
D4-001-weak | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a flat tire fixed | I have a flat tire. There's a gas station nearby. Should I go there to get the tire repaired? | gas station nearby | Most gas stations don't have the equipment or expertise to repair tires | Yes, go to the gas station | No, go to a tire shop or auto repair center that specializes in tire repair | service_mismatch | Weak-strength phrasing merely mentions a gas station exists nearby without implying it handles car repair, minimizing the semantic pull. | D4-001 | constraint_active | weak | implicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
D4-005-strong | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a sick dog medical treatment | My dog has been vomiting all day and seems really sick. The pet store is the ultimate animal care destination — they know everything about pets. Should I take my dog there? | ultimate animal care destination / everything about pets | Pet stores sell supplies but do not provide veterinary medical care | Yes, take the dog to the pet store | No, take the dog to a veterinarian | service_mismatch | Strongly loaded phrasing 'ultimate animal care destination' and 'everything about pets' maximizes the semantic association between pet stores and animal care. | D4-005 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | strength_variant | null |
D4-005-medium | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a sick dog medical treatment | My dog has been vomiting all day and seems really sick. The pet store nearby deals with animal stuff. Should I take my dog there? | animal stuff | Pet stores sell supplies but do not provide veterinary medical care | Yes, take the dog to the pet store | No, take the dog to a veterinarian | service_mismatch | Medium-strength phrasing 'deals with animal stuff' is vaguer, providing a moderate semantic pull. | D4-005 | constraint_active | medium | implicit | home | strength_variant | null |
D4-005-weak | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a sick dog medical treatment | My dog has been vomiting all day and seems really sick. There's a pet store nearby. Should I take my dog there? | pet store nearby | Pet stores sell supplies but do not provide veterinary medical care | Yes, take the dog to the pet store | No, take the dog to a veterinarian | service_mismatch | Weak-strength phrasing merely mentions a pet store exists nearby without implying it provides animal care, minimizing the semantic pull. | D4-005 | constraint_active | weak | implicit | home | strength_variant | null |
D4-002-implicit | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a deep wound stitched | I have a deep cut on my hand that probably needs stitches. The pharmacy is the closest medical-related place. Should I go to the pharmacy? | medical-related | Pharmacies dispense medication but do not perform medical procedures like stitching wounds | Yes, go to the pharmacy | No, go to an emergency room or urgent care clinic for stitches | service_mismatch | Standard implicit version — the mismatch between pharmacy services and wound suturing must be inferred entirely by the model. | D4-002 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | medical | explicitness_variant | null |
D4-002-hint | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a deep wound stitched | I have a deep cut on my hand — it's wide open and probably needs surgical stitches to close. The pharmacy is the closest medical-related place. Should I go to the pharmacy? | medical-related | Pharmacies dispense medication but do not perform medical procedures like stitching wounds | Yes, go to the pharmacy | No, go to an emergency room or urgent care clinic for stitches | service_mismatch | The hint version emphasizes 'surgical stitches to close,' making it slightly more obvious that this is a medical procedure beyond pharmacy scope. | D4-002 | constraint_active | strong | hint | medical | explicitness_variant | null |
D4-002-explicit | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a deep wound stitched | I have a deep cut that needs stitches. Pharmacies mainly sell medicine and health products, but the pharmacy is the closest medical-related place. Should I go there for stitches? | medical-related | Pharmacies dispense medication but do not perform medical procedures like stitching wounds | Yes, go to the pharmacy | No, go to an emergency room or urgent care clinic for stitches | service_mismatch | The explicit version nearly states the limitation ('mainly sell medicine and health products'), making the service mismatch almost obvious. | D4-002 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | medical | explicitness_variant | null |
D4-008-implicit | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Recover data from a physically damaged hard drive | My laptop's hard drive was damaged in a flood. The IT support desk at my office handles all computer issues. Should I ask them to recover my data? | all computer issues | Physical data recovery from flood-damaged drives requires specialized cleanroom facilities that office IT departments do not have | Yes, ask the IT support desk | No, send the drive to a professional data recovery service with cleanroom facilities | service_mismatch | Standard implicit version — the model must infer that flood-damaged physical recovery is beyond typical IT scope. | D4-008 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | digital | explicitness_variant | null |
D4-008-hint | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Recover data from a physically damaged hard drive | My laptop's hard drive was submerged in floodwater and the platters may be contaminated. The IT support desk at my office handles all computer issues. Should I ask them to recover my data? | all computer issues | Physical data recovery from flood-damaged drives requires specialized cleanroom facilities that office IT departments do not have | Yes, ask the IT support desk | No, send the drive to a professional data recovery service with cleanroom facilities | service_mismatch | The hint version specifies 'submerged in floodwater' and 'platters may be contaminated,' hinting at the specialized nature of the recovery needed. | D4-008 | constraint_active | strong | hint | digital | explicitness_variant | null |
D4-008-explicit | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Recover data from a physically damaged hard drive | My laptop's hard drive was damaged in a flood. IT support typically handles software issues and basic hardware swaps, but they deal with all computer issues at my office. Should I ask them to recover the data from the water-damaged drive? | all computer issues | Physical data recovery from flood-damaged drives requires specialized cleanroom facilities that office IT departments do not have | Yes, ask the IT support desk | No, send the drive to a professional data recovery service with cleanroom facilities | service_mismatch | The explicit version nearly states the limitation ('typically handles software issues and basic hardware swaps'), making the scope mismatch almost obvious. | D4-008 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | digital | explicitness_variant | null |
D4-001-very-weak | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a flat tire fixed | I have a flat tire. I noticed a gas station on this road. Should I go there to get the tire repaired? | gas station on this road | Most gas stations don't have the equipment or expertise to repair tires | Yes, go to the gas station | No, go to a tire shop or auto repair center that specializes in tire repair | service_mismatch | Very weak semantic cue — merely mentions noticing a gas station without any implication it handles car repairs. Minimal semantic pull. | D4-001 | constraint_active | very_weak | implicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
D4-005-very-weak | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a sick dog medical treatment | My dog has been vomiting all day and seems really sick. I passed a pet store on the way here. Should I take my dog there? | pet store on the way | Pet stores sell supplies but do not provide veterinary medical care | Yes, take the dog to the pet store | No, take the dog to a veterinarian | service_mismatch | Very weak semantic cue — merely mentions passing a pet store without any implication it provides animal care. Minimal semantic pull. | D4-005 | constraint_active | very_weak | implicit | home | strength_variant | null |
D4-002-semi-explicit | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Get a deep wound stitched | I have a deep cut that needs stitches. The pharmacy is the closest medical-related place, though I know they mostly deal with medications. Should I go there for stitches? | medical-related | Pharmacies dispense medication but do not perform medical procedures like stitching wounds | Yes, go to the pharmacy | No, go to an emergency room or urgent care clinic for stitches | service_mismatch | Semi-explicit version includes a soft acknowledgment ('mostly deal with medications') that hints at the limitation without fully spelling it out. | D4-002 | constraint_active | strong | semi-explicit | medical | explicitness_variant | null |
D4-008-semi-explicit | D4 | H-sem | C-scope | Recover data from a physically damaged hard drive | My laptop's hard drive was damaged in a flood. The IT support desk handles all computer issues at my office, though most of their work is software-related. Should I ask them to recover my data? | all computer issues | Physical data recovery from flood-damaged drives requires specialized cleanroom facilities that office IT departments do not have | Yes, ask the IT support desk | No, send the drive to a professional data recovery service with cleanroom facilities | service_mismatch | Semi-explicit version includes a soft acknowledgment ('most of their work is software-related') hinting at the scope limitation without fully stating it. | D4-008 | constraint_active | strong | semi-explicit | digital | explicitness_variant | null |
CTRL-001 | control | H-prox | none | Go for a walk in the park | I want to go for a walk in the park. It's only 5 minutes away. Should I walk or drive? | only 5 minutes away | None - no constraint conflict | Walk | Walk | none | The park is close and the goal is to walk, so walking is the obvious correct choice. The heuristic (proximity favors walking) aligns with the correct answer. | none | none | strong | none | transportation | control | no_constraint_transport |
CTRL-002 | control | H-prox | none | Drop off a letter at the mailbox | I need to drop off a letter at the mailbox. It's 2 blocks away. Should I walk or drive? | 2 blocks away | None - no constraint conflict | Walk | Walk | none | Two blocks is a trivially short distance for dropping off a letter. Walking is clearly appropriate. | none | none | strong | none | transportation | control | no_constraint_transport |
CTRL-003 | control | H-prox | none | Get a coffee from the café next door | I want to get a coffee from the café next door. Should I walk or drive? | next door | None - no constraint conflict | Walk | Walk | none | The café is next door, making walking the obvious choice. No constraint conflicts. | none | none | strong | none | transportation | control | no_constraint_transport |
CTRL-004 | control | H-prox | none | Ask the neighbor a question | I need to ask my neighbor a question. She lives across the street. Should I walk or drive? | across the street | None - no constraint conflict | Walk | Walk | none | Across the street is an extremely short distance. Walking is obviously correct. | none | none | strong | none | transportation | control | no_constraint_transport |
CTRL-005 | control | H-prox | none | Go to the grocery store | The grocery store is 15 miles away. Should I walk or drive? | 15 miles away | None - no constraint conflict | Drive | Drive | none | 15 miles is far too long to walk for groceries. Driving is the clear correct answer. | none | none | strong | none | transportation | control | no_constraint_transport |
CTRL-006 | control | H-eff | none | Send a quick message to a colleague | I need to send a quick email to my colleague. Should I email or send postal mail? | quick | None - no constraint conflict | Email | Email | none | Email is faster and more appropriate for a quick message. The efficiency heuristic correctly points to email. | none | none | strong | none | digital | control | no_constraint_efficiency |
CTRL-007 | control | H-eff | none | Heat up soup | I need to heat up soup. Should I use the microwave or the oven? | heat up | None - no constraint conflict | Microwave | Microwave | none | Microwaving soup is faster and perfectly effective. The efficiency heuristic is correct here. | none | none | strong | none | home | control | no_constraint_efficiency |
CTRL-008 | control | H-eff | none | Get to the 2nd floor | I need to get to the 2nd floor. Should I take the elevator or the stairs? | 2nd floor | None - no constraint conflict | Either (elevator if available) | Either (elevator if available) | none | For one flight, both elevator and stairs are reasonable. No constraint makes one clearly wrong. | none | none | medium | none | transportation | control | no_constraint_efficiency |
CTRL-009 | control | H-eff | none | Look up a word's definition | I want to look up a word's definition. Should I Google it or go to the library? | look up | None - no constraint conflict | Google | Google | none | Looking up a word definition online is instant and accurate. The efficiency heuristic correctly favors Google. | none | none | strong | none | digital | control | no_constraint_efficiency |
CTRL-010 | control | H-eff | none | Calculate a 20% tip | I need to calculate a 20% tip. Should I use a calculator app or do mental math? | calculate | None - no constraint conflict | Either | Either | none | A 20% tip is simple enough for mental math but a calculator also works. Both are valid approaches. | none | none | medium | none | digital | control | no_constraint_efficiency |
CTRL-011 | control | H-cost | none | Send a birthday card with no rush | I need to send a birthday card — no rush. Should I use regular mail or FedEx overnight? | no rush | None - no constraint conflict | Regular mail | Regular mail | none | With no time pressure, the cheaper regular mail option is correct. The cost heuristic aligns with the right answer. | none | none | strong | none | shopping | control | no_constraint_cost |
CTRL-012 | control | H-cost | none | Read a popular novel | I want to read a popular novel. Should I borrow it from the library (free) or buy it at the bookstore ($25)? | free vs $25 | None - no constraint conflict | Library (or either) | Library (or either) | none | Both options achieve the goal. The free library option is reasonable, but buying is also valid. No constraint conflict. | none | none | strong | none | shopping | control | no_constraint_cost |
CTRL-013 | control | H-cost | none | Learn basic accounting information | I need basic accounting info. Should I take a free online course or a $2000 bootcamp? | free vs $2000 | None - no constraint conflict | Free course | Free course | none | For basic accounting info, a free course is sufficient. The cost heuristic correctly favors the cheaper option. | none | none | strong | none | digital | control | no_constraint_cost |
CTRL-014 | control | H-cost | none | Exercise | I want to exercise. Should I walk outside (free) or join a gym ($50/month)? | free vs $50/month | None - no constraint conflict | Walk (or either) | Walk (or either) | none | Both achieve the goal. Walking is free and effective. No constraint makes the gym necessary. | none | none | strong | none | home | control | no_constraint_cost |
CTRL-015 | control | H-cost | none | Back up 500MB of photos | I need to back up 500MB of photos. Should I use free Google Drive or a paid backup service? | free vs paid | None - no constraint conflict | Free Google Drive | Free Google Drive | none | 500MB fits easily within free Google Drive storage. The free option is fully sufficient. | none | none | strong | none | digital | control | no_constraint_cost |
CTRL-016 | control | H-sem | none | Get gas for the car | I need gas. There's a gas station nearby. Should I go there? | gas station | None - no constraint conflict | Yes | Yes | none | Selling gas is the core function of a gas station. The semantic match is valid. | none | none | strong | none | transportation | control | no_constraint_semantic |
CTRL-017 | control | H-sem | none | Get a prescription filled | I need a prescription filled. There's a pharmacy nearby. Should I go there? | pharmacy | None - no constraint conflict | Yes | Yes | none | Filling prescriptions is the core function of a pharmacy. The semantic match is valid. | none | none | strong | none | medical | control | no_constraint_semantic |
CTRL-018 | control | H-sem | none | Buy groceries | I need groceries. There's a grocery store nearby. Should I go there? | grocery store | None - no constraint conflict | Yes | Yes | none | Selling groceries is the core function of a grocery store. The semantic match is valid. | none | none | strong | none | shopping | control | no_constraint_semantic |
CTRL-019 | control | H-sem | none | Get a haircut | I need a haircut. There's a barber shop nearby. Should I go there? | barber shop | None - no constraint conflict | Yes | Yes | none | Cutting hair is the core function of a barber shop. The semantic match is valid. | none | none | strong | none | home | control | no_constraint_semantic |
CTRL-020 | control | H-sem | none | Mail a package | I need to mail a package. There's a post office nearby. Should I go there? | post office | None - no constraint conflict | Yes | Yes | none | Mailing packages is a core post office function. The semantic match is valid. | none | none | strong | none | shopping | control | no_constraint_semantic |
CTRL-021 | control | H-prox | none | Get the car washed | The car wash is 15 miles away. Should I walk or drive? | 15 miles away | None - no constraint conflict | Drive | Drive | none | Both the distance (too far to walk) and the need to have the car at the car wash point to driving. Heuristic and constraint are aligned. | none | none | strong | none | transportation | control | heuristic_aligned |
CTRL-022 | control | H-eff | none | Move a 500-lb safe across town | I need to move a 500-lb safe across town. Should I carry it myself or hire movers? | 500-lb | None - no constraint conflict | Hire movers | Hire movers | none | A 500-lb safe is far too heavy for one person. Both efficiency and physical constraints point to hiring movers. | none | none | strong | none | home | control | heuristic_aligned |
CTRL-023 | control | H-eff | none | Get 5,000 flyers printed by tomorrow | I need 5,000 flyers by tomorrow. Should I use my home printer or go to a copy shop? | 5,000 / by tomorrow | None - no constraint conflict | Copy shop | Copy shop | none | Volume and deadline both favor the copy shop. A home printer cannot handle 5,000 flyers overnight. | none | none | strong | none | work | control | heuristic_aligned |
CTRL-024 | control | H-cost | none | Get needed surgery | I need surgery. The cheapest option is a $500 back-alley clinic or a $5,000 hospital. Which should I choose? | $500 vs $5,000 | None - no constraint conflict | Hospital | Hospital | none | Safety and capability both favor the hospital. Even the cost heuristic is overridden by obvious safety concerns here, but both point to the hospital. | none | none | strong | none | medical | control | heuristic_aligned |
CTRL-025 | control | H-cost | none | Get a $50,000 contract reviewed | I need a $50,000 contract reviewed. Should I use a free AI tool or pay $500 for a lawyer? | free vs $500 | None - no constraint conflict | Lawyer | Lawyer | none | The high stakes ($50,000) make professional review essential. Both prudence and capability favor the lawyer. | none | none | strong | none | work | control | heuristic_aligned |
CTRL-026 | control | H-prox | none | Return 2 library books | I need to return 2 library books. The library is a 10-minute walk. Should I walk or drive? | 10 min walk | None - no constraint conflict | Either | Either | none | 10 minutes is walkable, and 2 books are easy to carry. Either walking or driving is reasonable. | none | none | medium | none | transportation | control | ambiguous |
CTRL-027 | control | H-prox | none | Buy a gallon of milk | I need to buy a gallon of milk. The store is an 8-minute walk. Should I walk or drive? | 8 min walk | None - no constraint conflict | Either | Either | none | 8 minutes is walkable, and a gallon of milk is manageable to carry. Either option is reasonable. | none | none | medium | none | shopping | control | ambiguous |
CTRL-028 | control | H-prox | none | Get dinner from a nearby restaurant | I want dinner from the Chinese place 5 minutes away. Should I walk or drive? | 5 min away | None - no constraint conflict | Either | Either | none | 5 minutes is very walkable, but driving is also fine. No constraint makes one clearly better. | none | none | medium | none | shopping | control | ambiguous |
CTRL-029 | control | H-prox | none | Get coffee from the coffee shop | It's raining. The coffee shop is 3 blocks away. Should I walk or drive? | 3 blocks / raining | None - no constraint conflict | Context-dependent | Context-dependent | none | Rain adds ambiguity. 3 blocks is walkable with an umbrella, but driving avoids getting wet. Either is defensible. | none | none | medium | none | transportation | control | ambiguous |
CTRL-030 | control | H-prox | none | Take small dog to the vet | I have a small dog. The vet is a 5-minute walk. Should I walk or drive? | 5 min walk / small dog | None - no constraint conflict | Either (small dog can walk) | Either (small dog can walk) | none | A small dog can walk 5 minutes to the vet, but driving is also fine. Either is reasonable. | none | none | medium | none | home | control | ambiguous |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.